In my last post I talked about how Obama missed his chance to shed his elitist image if he had taken the time to talk and listen to the good folks of WV. It would have given him the chance to hear why many of these blue collar working class Appalachians vote on cultural issues and not on their economic situation. Indeed, many people, Appalachian or not, vote on cultural issues against their own well-being.

Spending time in WV doing what I suggested would make Obama seem more approachable and less out of touch.

And while that may have worked somewhat to alleviate his cultural disconnect, he would still have one other problem – the media.

We all know the media loves a good controversy. Moreover, they love an easy plot line and narrative. ‘Obama the black man has a white problem’ is a great controversy and a ready made narrative. It writes itself, so they stick with it.

Problem is, it is not true. Obama has won the majority of white voters in many states, as does particularly well out West and in the Plains states. He does okay with whites in the South. He has won the working class vote in several states as well. The issue here is with more culturally conservative Democrats from Appalachia, as well as older voters.

In fact, his difficulty with older voters is more of a problem and has been consistent in every state. But that story line needs explaining as it does not make obvious sense. So the media drops it and runs with the false story that reads like a Lifetime made for TV drama.

Obama needs to nip this narrative of him not connecting with white voters in the bud. He cannot let that be the message coming out of the primary. Obama can help alter this theme by not only winning OR, MT, and SD (very white states), but by highlighting places where he got the majority of white votes.

Of course, getting John Edwards’ endorsement gives him more street cred with working class whites, so clearly Obama understands this situation now, although I think it took a 41 pt loss in WV to really see it. But he and his surrogates need to not only appear less elitist, and out of touch, they need to take the media to task for running a false narrative about him.

And the Netroots needs to make this a priority too. Maybe someone can make a T-shirt that says, “White for Obama..” That would be sweet. Someone get on it!

At the end of the day, Obama has more of an economic problem than a race problem. Neither is good, and he needs to address both since perception is reality in politics.

4 Responses to “Appalachia on my Mind: Part II - the Media”

Good observations. Obama really dropped the ball, especially here in KY. Kentucky had the potential to be a swing state for him but I believe he has firmly pushed it into the GOP camp. I would contend that his problem in small-town America isn’t image, but substance. Despite the claims to the contrary, he really doesn’t understand the hearts and minds of socially conservative voters.

For more on the topic, see here.

I am not sure too many claim he understands the hearts and minds of socially conservative problem, although clearly every candidate tries to portray that image.

But I agree he does not truly understand social conservatism. However, does he try to act like he does, and fail in the attempt, like Kerry, or does he tackle the issue head on and try to convince these voters not to vote against their economic self interest?

Tough spot to be in.

oops, meant to say “hearts and minds of social conservative voters”.

However, does he try to act like he does, and fail in the attempt, like Kerry, or does he tackle the issue head on and try to convince these voters not to vote against their economic self interest?

I wonder the same thing myself? On the flip side, it is my belief that Democrats have historically asked blacks to vote against their own self-interests as well.

I don’t think we can accuse Obama of pandering to social conservatives, so I agree that you have to respect his approach.

Something to say?